On the surface, this looks like a good idea. But then on the surface these things often do. The devil as always is in the details.
Teacher certification will change from a standardized test to an amorphous collage of lesson plans, homework assignments and lectures.
Who will judge the performance of these teachers newbie on their lesson plans, homework assignments, and lecture videos? Here is where the stink creeps in: the judging will be done by outsourcers trained by Pearson (the corporation sell the materials) to evaluate the teacher newbie. So not experts. Likely not even Americans.
Will this make schools better, or just enrich another corporation that sells training materials?
With New Standards, Going Beyond Paper and Pencil to License Teachers - NYTimes.com
The change is an attempt to ensure that those who become teachers not only know education theories, but also can show the ability to lead classrooms and handle students of differing abilities and needs, often amid limited resources.
It is also a reaction to a criticism of some teachers’ colleges, which have been accused of minting diplomas but failing to prepare teachers for the kind of real-world experience where creativity and flexibility can be the keys to success.
The new licensing standards will be required next year in Washington State and have been committed to in Minnesota. New York will impose the new standards starting in 2014 with the estimated 62,000 students expected to graduate with teaching degrees.
New York and up to 25 other states are moving toward changing the way they grant licenses to teachers, de-emphasizing tests and written essays in favor of a more demanding approach that requires aspiring teachers to prove themselves through lesson plans, homework assignments and videotaped instruction sessions.
. . .